So, you’ve decided it’s time for a pool and you’re ready to dive in. But finding the right one is where it gets tricky. Between installation timelines, design options, and long-term upkeep, there’s a lot to weigh up. You want something that suits your lifestyle, looks great in your yard, and won’t keep you waiting all summer. Whether you're tossing up between a plunge pool or a traditional above ground pool, making the right choice is key to getting the most out of your yard. 

Above ground pools are an increasingly popular choice for homeowners right now. They bring style, value, and practicality to your yard without breaking the bank or eating up all your space. They used to be the go-to for quick and affordable setups, and the evolution of plunge pools has made them even more popular. But, when it comes to choosing between a plunge pool and a traditional above ground pool, what’s the real difference, and which one will suit your lifestyle best? 

Here’s what you need to know before making the call. 

Feature by Feature Pool Comparison 

Gone are the days when above ground pools were considered a temporary fix, something you could set up, splash around in for a season, then pack away (or, let’s face it, forget about) when the warm weather ended.   

Compact, concrete, and crane-in ready, a plunge pool brings the cooling benefits of a full-sized pool without taking over your whole yard.  

So, why are plunge pools a better option for modern Americans?  

Why More Americans Are Choosing Plunge Pools  

With yard sizes shrinking across the country, more Americans are opting for plunge pools to maximize their outdoor spaces. Today, the average size of new single-family home lots is under 9,000 square feet, a significant drop from the larger properties of the past. 

That smaller block size makes plunge pools the perfect option with their: 

• Compact design—plunge pools deliver the cooling relief of a traditional pool without taking up all your space. 

• Quick installation—precast off-site and craned into position, Plungie pools are ready up to 74% faster than a traditional pool.  

• Flexible options—Whether you need a pool that fits snugly into a smaller yard or one that makes a statement, plunge pools can be sized to suit your needs. Plus, with a range of ecoFinish interior coating colors, you can personalize the look of your pool to perfectly complement your outdoor space. 

• Accessories and add-ons—like an auto top-up valve, accessory holders for umbrellas, drinks ,and coolers.

Traditional above-ground pools, on the other hand, are great for those seeking a quick and portable summer solution that can be disassembled at the end of the season. 

Installation Options That Work With Your Space 

One of the biggest differences between a plunge pool and a traditional above ground pool lies in how it’s installed and how flexible that installation can be. 

Plungie pools are designed to adapt to a wide range of backyard configurations, with four different install heights to choose from:

• Fully above ground – a practical and stylish solution, especially where excavation isn’t possible or cost-effective.  
  
• Semi-recessed - ideal for sloped sites or where partial elevation enhances your design. This style of install also works well where a subtle elevation that adds dimension while keeping a low profile. 
  
• Fully in-ground – sleek and streamlined, this option integrates seamlessly into your landscape or deck. 

Because Plungie pools are precast and fully self-supporting, there’s no need for retaining walls or additional structural support, unlike traditional above ground pools, which often require more time, trades, and cost to complete. This makes Plungie an ideal choice for small or sloping yards, where space and level ground can be limited. 

Maintenance and Care 

Not all pools age the same. Traditional above ground pools typically rely on steel walls and vinyl liners which can fade, warp, and wear out over time. They also need extra structures like decking or barriers to stay secure and safe, which means more to maintain long term. 

Plungie pools are built differently. Made from precast concrete, they’re self-supporting, strong, and made to last. That means fewer moving parts, no risk of rust or liner tears, and no surprises down the track. 

The differences add up: less maintenance, fewer materials to worry about, and more time to enjoy the lifestyle your pool was built for. 

The Smarter Choice Starts Here 

Choosing between a plunge pool and a traditional above ground setup? With Plungie, you don’t have to compromise on style, durability or value. Take the first step toward a backyard you’ll never want to leave: design your own Plungie and get in touch with our friendly team today. 

Frequently Asked Questions 

What is a plunge pool? 
A plunge pool is a compact, deep pool perfect for relaxing and cooling off. It's designed to fit smaller spaces, offering all the benefits of a pool without taking over your backyard.  

Can a Plungie be installed fully above ground? 

Yes! All Plungie pools are self-supporting, which means they can be installed above ground, semi-recessed or fully in-ground depending on your space and preference. 

Is a plunge pool better than a traditional above ground pool? 

That depends on what you’re after. If you're looking for something that’s durable, stylish and adds value to your property, a concrete plunge pool like a Plungie is the smarter long-term investment. However, if you’d like to take your pool with you when you move, a traditional above ground pool that can be disassembled may be the better solution. 

What’s the smallest plunge pool size available? 

Our smallest model, the Plungie Studio, takes up just 0.5% of the average American lot size at 12 x 7 feet. Perfect for tight spaces and urban living. 

Can I customize how my Plungie looks? 

Absolutely. From interior finishes and tiling to landscaping and decking, Plungie pools are designed to blend seamlessly into your dream outdoor space.